Teacher-student relationships are primarily functional, not sentimental.

Most of us probably remember a teacher we had great affection for. As a piano and organ teacher, I have noticed that working one-on-one with students over multiple years often creates more personal bonds than when I was teaching twenty students together for one fleeting year. While these teacher-student relationships are very meaningful, I find I often have to reinforce to beginning and elementary-level adult students that music lessons are primarily a functional relationship and not a sentimental one.

The point of taking private music lessons is to gain skills. It is education you are signing up for when you sign up for music lessons. If you are doing what you should as a student, you should see obvious improvement in yourself every week, if not every day. If you are attending weekly lessons and practicing every day and you are NOT seeing improvement, you may not be on the same page as your teacher, or you may need to explore how different teachers might fit you as a learner.

In my experience, it is easy for a student to feel personally offended if I suggest they try other teachers. There shouldn’t be any reason for this. If a particular doctor doesn’t have the skills to treat my condition, I don’t get offended. I try a different doctor. If the local appliance store doesn’t have a tv that fits my space, I don’t get offended. I try a different store. Teachers know that they are not what every student needs. While I have a great track record of figuring out how individuals think in a way that helps me help them learn, my ability to be effective with every individual will never be 100%, and no one should expect this.

Occasionally, prospective adult students inquire who are not particularly interested in learning the basics of music. The overwhelming majority of piano teachers are not trained in music therapy. From my perspective, it is not reasonable to approach a piano teacher wanting a relationship that seeks general companionship, an instant parent, a weekly social call, or a session to talk about life or current affairs. These are all important, valid needs in life, but they are not what piano teachers are trained to do and not what they signed up for.

It is absolutely essential that students possess a real desire to learn music and a real ability to face and evaluate themselves on a daily basis. The student has to be the one in the steam engine shoveling coal into the fire. Your teacher is there to help you steer.

Next
Next

The Myth of “I’ll Just Take Longer to Become Fluent”